Loving Annabelle is not just a movie — it’s a moment in LGBTQ+ cinema history. But beyond the emotional story on-screen, the making of the film was filled with fascinating details, creative risks, and personal connections. In this post, we take you behind the scenes of Loving Annabelle to uncover the facts that make it even more unforgettable.
1. The Film Was Shot in Just 18 Days
Despite its polished look and emotional depth, Loving Annabelle was completed on a tight indie schedule — filmed over just 18 days in Los Angeles. This fast-paced shoot demanded intense commitment from cast and crew.
2. Based on the Director’s Real-Life Experiences
Director Katherine Brooks attended Catholic school and drew from her own struggles with identity and conformity. She’s said the story of Annabelle and Simone is deeply personal.
“There’s truth in every scene, even if the names and faces are fictional.”
3. Inspired by a 1931 Lesbian Classic
Loving Annabelle is partly inspired by the 1931 German film Mädchen in Uniform, one of the earliest cinematic representations of a lesbian relationship — also set in an all-girls boarding school.
4. Erin Kelly and Diane Gaidry Met Just Before Filming
The chemistry between Annabelle (Erin Kelly) and Simone (Diane Gaidry) was undeniable — and surprisingly, they had just met a day before filming began. Their on-screen connection was built quickly but felt deeply real.
5. The Music Was Hand-Picked by the Director
The haunting and emotional soundtrack of the film was personally selected by Katherine Brooks. It includes music from indie artists that enhanced the raw and intimate mood.
6. The School Was a Real Catholic Campus
The movie was filmed at an actual Catholic school in Los Angeles, adding an authentic feel to the setting. However, the school didn’t know the exact plot details.
7. An Alternate Ending Was Considered
Early versions of the script included a different ending where Annabelle and Simone run away together, but Brooks opted for a more realistic and emotionally powerful conclusion.
8. It Won Awards at LGBTQ+ Film Festivals
Though it wasn’t a mainstream blockbuster, Loving Annabelle received praise at several LGBTQ+ festivals, including Outfest and the Paris Lesbian & Feminist Film Festival.
9. Real Dialogue Was Used from Fan Letters
Some lines in the film were inspired by fan letters sent to Katherine Brooks from LGBTQ+ teens around the world. The director read their stories and infused their pain and courage into the script.
10. Diane Gaidry Passed Away in 2016
Diane Gaidry, who played Simone, sadly passed away from cancer in 2016. Her performance remains one of the most poignant elements of the film and continues to touch viewers worldwide.
Final Thoughts
Behind the haunting beauty of Loving Annabelle lies a passionate story of indie filmmaking, personal truths, and brave storytelling. Understanding how the film was made only deepens the appreciation for what it represents.